Home » Currently Reading:

WHISK(E)Y REVIEWS



Under Construction ………….

 Distillery  Expression  Notes  Grade
 Aberfeldy  21 year old  B-
 Aberlour  10 year old
 Aberlour  12 year old
 Aberlour  16 year old
 Aberlour  18 year old
 Aberlour  A’bunadh, Batch 16  A-
 Aberlour  A’bunadh, Batch 21  A-
 Aberlour  A’bunadh, Batch 37  A-
 Aberlour  A’bunadh, Batch 39  A-
 Aberlour  A’bunadh, Batch 41  B+
 Aberlour  Scott’s Selection, 1989, 20 year old  B
 Ambassador  Deluxe Scotch Blend 8 year old  C+
 Amrut  Double Cask – Casks 2874 and 2273  B
 An Cnoc  12 year old
 An Cnoc  16 year old  B
 Ardbeg  10 year old  B
 Ardbeg  Uigeadail  A-
 Ardbeg  Corryvreckan  A-
 Ardbeg  Alligator  B+
 Ardbeg  Supernova  B+
 Ardbeg  Day  B
 Ardbeg  Gallileo  B-
 Ardbeg  SMWS 23.70, Campfire by sea cliffs, 9 year  B+
 Ardbeg
 Ardmore  30 year old, Bottle 848 / 1428  B+
 Ardmore  30 year old, Bottle 772 / 1428  B+
 Ardmore  Peated Traditional Cask
 Arran  10 year old  B-
 Arran  14 year old  B
 Arran  Amarone Finish  B-
 Arran  Sauternes Finish  Glazed Donuts  B
 Arran  Port Finish  B-
 Arran  Single Cask, Sherry, 1996, 15 year old
 Arran  11 year old, 1998
 Arran  The Devil’s Punch Bowl  B+
 Arran  Single Cask Sherry, 12 year
 Arran  Sherry Single Cask 226
 Balblair  2001 First Release, 10 year old
 Balblair  1997 12 year old
 Balblair  1975, Batch 2  A-
 Balmenach  Duncan Taylor, NC2, 2000, 9 year old  B
 Balvenie  12 year Double Wood
 Balvenie  15 year Single Barrel
 Balvenie  21 year Port Wood
 Balvenie  14 year Rum Cask, Cuban Selection
 Balvenie  17 year Double Wood
 Balvenie  Tun 1401 Batch 3  A-
 Balvenie  Tun 1401 Batch 6  B+
 Balvenie  30 year old
 Bendromach  25 year old
 Benriach  27 year old, 1984, K&L Exclusive, PX  B
 Big Peat  Islay Blended Malt.  B
 Black Bottle  C+
 Bladnoch  Chieftain’s, 1992, 18 year old  Sweet, Spring, Hay  B+
 Bladnoch  Scott’s Selection, 20 year old  Strawberry Shortcake  B
 Blair Athol  Duncan Taylor, 1989, 23 year old
 Bowmore  Jack Wiebers Wanted The Loving Brothers  6 year old, Sherry
 Bowmore  12 year old
 Bowmore  15 year old Darkest
 Bowmore  18 year old
 Bowmore  21 year old
 Bowmore  25 year old
 Bowmore  Silver Seal Whisky Company, 21 year old
 Bowmore  SMWS 3.182: Peeling Tangerines in Hospital  21 year old  B
 Bowmore  SMWS 3.171: Peasant Honey and Lime Flowers  20 year old  B
 Bowmore  Whisky-Fässle, Duck Edition, 1997 15 year  B+
 Bowmore  Dusk, Bourdeaux Wine Cask  B
 Bruichladdich
 Bruichladdich  Black Art 2, 1989, 21 year old
 Bruichladdich  Connoisseur Choice, 1991, 14 year old
 Bruichladdich  Octomore 2.1, 140ppm
 Bruichladdich  Octomore 4.2 Comus, 167ppm
 Bruichladdich  Octomore 4.1, 167 ppm
 Bruichladdich  2003, Peated, K&L Exclusive  B
 Bruichladdich  Port Charlotte PC 9
 Bruichladdich  Scott’s Selection, 1990, 14 year old
 Bruichladdich  SMWS 23.72: A Big Eye Watering Slap  9 year old  B
 Bunnahabhain  Scott’s Selection, 1977, 28 year old
 Caol Ila  Berry Bros & Rudd, 2000, 10 yo  B
 Caol Ila  Gordon & MacPhail, Port Wood Fin., 1998  9 yr old  B-
 Caol Ila  Nectar of the Daily Dram, 18 year old  B
 Caol Ila  The Whisky Agency, 19 year old  B+
 Caol Ila  Silver Seal Whisky Company, 28 year  A
 Caol Ila  SMWS 53.157: Paint Your Own Picture  10 yr old  B
 Caol Ila  SMWS 53.162: The Happiness Machine  16 yr old  A-
 Caol Ila  SMWS 53.144: Buckets of Tar and Brine  20 yr old
 Caol Ila  Scott’s Selection, 1981, 30 year old  A-
 Caol Ila  Scott’s Selection, 1984  B
 Caperdonach  18 year old, 1994, K&L Exclusive  B-
 Chichibu  The First
 Clynelish  Signatory Vintage, 1998, 11 year old
 Coleburn  A.D. Rattray, 1983, 25 year old
 Connemara  Bog Oak, Batch VII
 Connemara  Turf Mor
 Cooley  A.D. Rattray, Cask Collection, 11 year old  Irish
 Corsair  Triple Smoke  C+
 Corsair  Pumpkin Spice Moonshine  D
 Corsair  Wry Moon  D
 Corsair  Ryemageddon  C-
 Craigellachie  12 year old, 1999, Sherry
 Croftengea  Single Cask Peated, 1997, 8 year old
 Dailuaine  SMWS 41.47: Bentley in Zanzibar  7 year, Yummy  A-
 Faultline  10 year old North Highland  Rumor:Glenmorangie  B-
 George T. Stagg  Hot, lots of alcohol  A-
 Glann ar Mor  Kornog Taouarc’h Eilvet 2009
 Glenallachie  1974, sherry cask  2011 Whisky Exchange
 Glendronach  14 year old, Sauterenes Finish
 Glendronach  Revival, 15 year, Sherry Cask  B
 Glendronach  1993, 19 year old, K&L Exclusive  B-
 Glenfarclas  105
 Glenfarclas  1996, For Traverso’s, 11 year old
 Glenfarclas  12 year old
 Glenfarclas  1970, 42 year old, K&L Exclusive  B+
 Glenfarclas  40 year old  B+
 Glenfarclas  1972
 Glenfarclas  1982
 Glenfarclas  25 year old
 Glenfiddich  1959, Cask 3935  Nth Superpour
 Glenfiddich  18 year old
 Glenfiddich  12 year old
 Glenfiddich  15 year Solera Reserve
 Glenfiddich  20 year, 8 years in Rum  Interesting
 Glenlivet  12 year old
 Glenlivet  15 year old
 Glenlivet  Nadura  Citrus. Refreshing.  B
 Glenlivet  Archive 21 year old
 Glenlivet  XXV, 25 year old
 Glenlivet  Scott’s Selection, 1977, 27 year old
 Glenlivet  18 year old
 Glen Garioch  12 year old
 Glen Garioch  1994 Vintage, Batch 32
 Glen Garioch  1998 Vintage, 14 year old, K&L Exclusive  B-
 Glenglassaugh  26 year old
 Glenglassaugh  37 year old, 1974
 Glengoyne  Single Cask, 1987, 24 year old
 Glen Grant  Malt Trust, 1979, 28 year old  B+
 Glen Grant  Malt Trust, 1975, 32 year old  B
 Glen Mohr  Scott’s Selection, 1978, 26 year old
 Glenmorangie  Quinta Ruban, 12 year old, Port finish
 Glenmorangie  Finealta  B-
 Glenmorangie  Sonnalta PX
 Glenmorangie  Madeira Wood Finish, 12 year old
 Glen Moray  SMWS 35.47: Jelly Tots and Iced Gems  15 year old  B
 Glen Moray  Single Cask Nation, 12 year old  12 year old  A-
 Glenrothes  Select Reserve
 Glenrothes  1998 Vintage
 Glenrothes  1995 Vintage  B
 Glenrothes  1988 Vintage
 Glenrothes  Scott’s Selection, 1973, 30 year old
 Glenrothes  The Macphail’s Collection, 8 year old
 Glenrothes  Single Cask for Binny’s, 1994, 11 year old
 Glenrothes  Signatory, Unchillfiltered, 1990, 13 year old
 Glen Scotia  17 yr, 1991, Murray McDavid, Port Finish
 Grant’s  Family Reserve  Not good  D
 Hakushu  12 year old  Fresh forrest  B+
 Hazelburn  8 year old, 2002, Spring Bank
 Hellyers Road  Tasmanian Single Malt, Peated
 Hibiki  12 year old
 Highland Park  12 year old
 Highland Park  15 year old
 Highland Park  18 year old  B
 Highland Park  25 year old  B
 Highland Park  30 year old  Good.  B-
 Highland Park  50 year old  Kind of boring.  B-
 Highland Park  Signatory Vintage, 1991, 17 year old
 Highland Park  Scott’s Selection, 1986
 Highland Park  Scott’s Selection, 1977, 21 year old
 Highland Park  Thor, 16 year old
 Highland Park  1977 Bicentenary
 Hudson  Single Malt
 Ichiro’s Malt  Chichibu The First, 2008  B
 Imperial  Duncan Taylor, 1995, 17 year old
 Inchgower  30 year old, 1982, Old Malt Cask
 Inchmurrin  10 year old, Loch Lomand
 Isle of Jura  Superstition  B
 Isle of Jura  Archives 3rd Release, 1998, 24 year old
 Johnny Walker  Black  C+
 Johnny Walker  Blue  Smooth, too smooth  B-
 Johnny Walker  Double Black  B-
 Johnny Walker  Green, 15 year, Vatted Malt  Asian pear, peat, oak  B
 Johnny Walker  Gold  B
 Kilchoman  Machir Bay, 2012  A
 Kilchoman  5 year old, Single Sherry Cask  A-
 Kilchoman  Single Cask Nation, 2007, 4 yr, ex bourbon  A-
 Kilchoman  2006 Vintage  A-
 Kilchoman  100% Islay, Single Sherry Cask, K&L Exclus.  A
 Lagavulin  12 year old Cask Strength  A-
 Lagavulin  16 year old  B+
 Laphroaig  10 year  daily drinker  B+
 Laphroaig  10 year Cask Strength Batch 2  A-
 Laphroaig  10 year Cask Strength Batch 3  A-
 Laphroaig  15 year  cupcakes and bandaids  B-
 Laphroaig  18 year  B
 Laphroaig  21 year Cask Stength  A
 Laphroaig  30 year
 Laphroaig  40 year
 Laphroaig  Cairdeas 2011
 Laphroaig  Cairdeas 2012  B
 Laphroaig  Quarter Cask  B+
 Laphroaig  Triple Wood  anise, blackcurrant
 Laphroaig  PX Cask
 Laphroaig  SMWS 29.100: A League of its Own  A
 Laphroaig  SMWS 29.103: Autumn Equinox on Islay  13 year old
 Laphroaig  SMWS 29.115: Candy Floss in a Fairground  22 year old
 Laphroaig  C & S Dram Collection, 11 year old  Hogshead
 Laphroaig  Cheiftain’s, 14 year old B+
 Laphroaig  The Ultimate 1998, 13 year old  Refill butt
 Laphroaig  New Make  should bottle this
 Laphroaig  Signatory Vintage, 2001, 8 year old
 Laphroaig  Signatory Vintage CS, 1990, 19 year old
 Laphroaig  Signatory Vintage UCC, 2000, 9 year old B+
 Laphroaig  Cadenhead’s, Sherrywood Matured, 12 yr  B+
 Lark  Tasmania  B-
 Lark  Distiller’s Edition  B
 Lark  11 year old, Cask Strength  B
 Ledaig  Alambique Classic, 1972, 37 yr, Oloroso  B+
 Ledaig  Gordon and Macphail for Binny’s, 16 year  B
 Ledaig  10 year old  B-
 Linkwood  Chieftan 1991, 16 year old
 Linkwood  SMWS 39.22: Gingersnaps  13 y.o.
 Lochside  Connoisseurs Choice, 1991, 13 year old
 Longmorn  Signatory Vintage, 1992, 17 year old
 Longrow  1994, 11 year old
 Longrow  CV, Spring Bank  Peaty
 Lost Spirits  Leviathan II – Peated  Weird  C
 Macallan  Fine Oak, 10 year old
 Macallan  Sherry Oak, 12 year old
 Macallan  Fine Oak, 15 year old
 Macallan  Fine Oak, 17 year old
 Macallan  Sherry Oak, 18 year old
 Macallan  Sherry Oak, Cask Strength, 10 yo  B+
 Macallan  Kirkland Signature 20 year, Sherry Finish  2011 Costco  B-
 Macallan  Scott’s Selection, 1989, 18 year old  B
 Mackinlay’s  Shackleton Rare Old Highland Malt
 Maker’s Mark  Standard  B-
 Maker’s Mark  Maker’s 46  B+
 Master of Malt  Peatin’ Meetin’ 2012
 Millstone  Peated, 5 year old
 Monkey Shoulder  Triple Malt – Glenfiddich, Balvenie, Kinivie
 Mortlach  Gordon and Macphail CS, 1993, 13 y.o.
 Mortlach  Chieftan’s, Sherry Butt, 15 year old  B+
 Mortlach  Chieftan’s, Sherry Butt, 22 year old  A-
 Oban  14 year old  C
 Oban  18 year old  Cherries, Morning Mist  B-
 Oban  Distiller’s Edition 1995 Double Matured
 Oban  Distiller’s Edition 1996 Double Matured
 Old Ballantruan  Peated Malt from Tomintoul
 Old Pulteney  Whisky Galore, 1989, 16 ear old
 Old Pulteney  17 year old
 Old Pulteney  30 year old
 Pappy Van Winkle  15 year old  A
 Pappy Van Winkle  20 year old  B+
 Peregrine Rock  California Pure Malt Whisky  Peated
 Port Ellen  Elements of Islay, PE 3
 Port Ellen  Scott’s Selection, 1982, 23 year old
 Red Breast  12 year old Cask Strength Pure Pot Still Irish  B+
 Speyside  Kirkland Signature 20 year, Sherry Finish  One-note  C+
 Spring Bank  10 year old
 Spring Bank  Berry Bros and Rudd, 1994
 Spring Bank  Rundles and Kilderkins, 2001
 Spring Bank  25 year old, Millennium Edition
 Spring Bank  21 year old
 Spring Bank  SMWS 27.88: The dignity of labour  13 year old  B
 St. George’s  The English Whisky Co. Chapter 11
 Talisker  30 year old
 Tomintoul  Malts of Scotland, 2001, 11 year old
 Usquaebach  Reserve Blended  B-
 Usquaebach  15 Year Old Vatted Malt  B-
 Usquaebach  Old Rare Blended  B
 Willet  Family Estate Single Barrel Bourbon  B
 Yamazaki  12 year old  For Relaxing Times  B
 Yamazaki  18 year old  B

That’s it.